NYC Cookies Co.
Peanut Butter Overload Cookie
Peanut Butter Overload Cookie
Couldn't load pickup availability
The name is not an exaggeration. Our 5 oz Peanut Butter Overload is loaded with Reese’s Pieces and Reese’s Oreos, stuffed with a peanut butter center, then finished with a crunchy chocolate peanut butter spread and crushed peanut butter Oreo across the top. Four kinds of peanut butter in one cookie. Handmade in Brooklyn, baked fresh to order.
Flavor Profile
Perfect For
Ingredients
Unsalted butter, light brown sugar, granulated sugar, eggs, pure vanilla extract, creamy peanut butter, King Arthur all-purpose flour, cornstarch, salt, baking soda, Reese’s Pieces, Reese’s Oreo cookies, crunchy chocolate peanut butter spread, peanut butter Oreo cookies
Contains
May Contain
Send The Whole Box
A carefully curated selection of twelve gourmet cookies, hand-picked from what is freshest that week.
Every cookie individually wrapped, arranged in our signature white gift box.
Why NYC Cookies Co.
Shipping
📦 Nationwide shipping — USPS Priority Mail, 1–3 days in transit. Calculated at checkout.
📅 Baked to order — allow 1–2 days for baking before your order ships.
🚲 Brooklyn delivery — $12 flat fee, $50 minimum, select zip codes.
☀ Warm weather — chocolate-finished cookies may soften in transit during summer months. We pack accordingly, but we recommend expedited shipping in hot climates.
Each cookie arrives individually sealed in a frosted bag to lock in freshness. Stays fresh 5–7 days at room temperature. Freeze for up to 3 months. Warm for 15 seconds for that fresh-baked gooey center.
