A Temptation You
Can Give Into.

Get The Collection

Gourmet 3.5 oz Cookies

1 6
View all

Brownies

What Makes Our Cookies Special?

♥

Made with Love

Every cookie is handcrafted with care and passion in our Brooklyn kitchen.

✦

Small Batch

Baked in small batches so every cookie gets the attention it deserves.

✿

No Preservatives

Only real ingredients. No preservatives, no additives, no shortcuts.

♦

Perfect for Gifting

Beautifully packaged and ready to make someone's day special.

Our Story

"At NYC Cookies Co, we believe that the best things in life are homemade — especially the cookies."

Born in the heart of Brooklyn and built from a love of baking and sharing joy. Every batch is made with real ingredients, real care, and a whole lot of love. No shortcuts, no preservatives — just fresh cookies made to order.

NEW DROP

The Cookie Butter Drip

Born from brown butter, filled with Biscoff soul, drizzled with white chocolate. Our most requested cookie is here.

ORDER NOW

What Our Customers Say

★★★★★

"These cookies are INSANE. The cookie butter one had me ordering a second box before I finished the first. Shae is doing something special in that Brooklyn kitchen."

Sarah M. — Flatbush

★★★★★

"Ordered the Gift Box for my sister's birthday. She called me crying happy tears. The packaging was beautiful and the cookies were FRESH."

Marcus T. — Bed-Stuy

★★★★★

"I've tried every cookie delivery in NYC. Nothing comes close. No preservatives and you can taste the difference. Chef's kiss."

Jasmine R. — Crown Heights

Leave a Review

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

Shipping & Delivery

🚲

Brooklyn Delivery

$8.00 flat fee. Minimum order $45. Order with 4 hours lead time - same day delivery available based on order time. We will confirm your delivery window.

📦

NY State Shipping

We ship anywhere in New York State via FedEx 2-Day. Orders placed Mon-Thu ship same week. Orders placed Fri-Sun ship the following Monday. Minimum order $65.

🎁

Custom Orders

Planning something special? We do custom orders for birthdays, weddings, and events. Email us to discuss.

Frequently Asked Questions

Yes — our cookies contain wheat, dairy, eggs, and soy. Some products contain tree nuts and peanuts. Each product page lists specific allergens.
Our cookies stay fresh for 5-7 days when stored in an airtight container at room temperature. For longer storage, they freeze beautifully for up to 3 months.
We offer local delivery in Brooklyn, Queens, The Bronx, Staten Island, and Long Island. We also ship throughout New York State ONLY via FedEx 2-Day. We are an NYS approved cottage bakery. As much as we want you to taste our delicious treats- we have to comply with our state regulation. Make sure to add us on your list of things to do when in NYC 💗Orders placed Mon-Thu ship same week. Fri-Sun orders ship the following Monday. Minimum order $65. Plan accordingly.
Yes! Add your message in the notes section at checkout. We'll include a handwritten card with your order.
Yes! Email us at Cookiequeen@nyccookiesco.com for wholesale pricing and minimum order details.

Send Shae a Message

Questions, custom orders, or just want to say hi?

Cookiequeen@nyccookiesco.com | BKLYN, NY 11234